Image default

MLB rumors: Imagining a Yankees-Phillies commerce blockbuster to reshape each rosters

Let’s get nuts.

Because the Yankees get set to invade Residents Financial institution Park and tackle the Phillies this weekend, each franchises are caught.

The Yankees are caught with an underachieving membership that lacks lineup steadiness, athleticism and a real No. 2 behind ace Gerrit Cole.

The Phillies are caught with a core that has no concept the right way to win, unhealthy protection and no approach out of a top-heavy roster with little monetary flexibility after blowing near a billion {dollars} on gamers during the last 4 years. Philadelphia is watching essentially the most mediocre staff cash should buy.

Introducing Yankees Insider: Get unique information, behind-the-scenes observations and the power to textual content message straight with beat writers

Right here’s an concept for a six-player blockbuster commerce which will look excessive, however may very well be precisely what every staff wants to alter its collective DNA and attain its ceiling.

Yankees get: 1B Rhys Hoskins, SS Didi Gregorius, SP Aaron Nola

Phillies get: SS Gleyber Torres, OF Clint Frazier, SP Deivi Garcia

Would each groups do it? I feel there’s a greater likelihood of that occurring than you would possibly suppose. Right here’s why both sides (Yankees’ Brian Cashman and Phillies’ Dave Dombrowski) may pull the set off on a blockbuster like this.

Why the Yankees would do it

Hoskins is their type of offensive participant, and first base stays a gap: Hoskins represents how Cashman’s finest offenses have performed for years: Energy and persistence. Since coming into the league in August 2017, Hoskins has hit 103 dwelling runs and walked 289 occasions. Right here’s a full checklist of gamers to succeed in these marks because the begin of 2017: Mike Trout, Aaron Choose, Bryce Harper, Paul Goldschmidt, Freddie Freeman, Christian Yelich, Mookie Betts, Alex Bregman and Hoskins. For the primary time since Mark Teixeira declined, the Yankees may have a long-term reply at this place.

Lineup steadiness is a should, and Gregorius’ absence has been felt: The Yankees have missed Gregorius since letting him go. The lineup is just too right-handed with out his lefty energy stick. The clubhouse and dugout don’t appear as unfastened. Each staff has a glue man. Gregorius was this staff’s glue man. Though he’s been on the IL, Gregorius is on a rehab task and virtually again. He’d be a welcome addition, and an offended fan base would love the transfer.

Shopping for low on Nola may very well be a steal, in a number of methods: This may very well be the neatest a part of the deal for Cashman. Nola was arguably a top-10 pitcher within the sport from 2018-2021. To this point in 2021? Not a lot. Command is gone. His ERA is north of 4. However we’re speaking a couple of pitcher with a observe report, swing-and-miss stuff and one of the vital team-friendly (owed simply $31.5M over the subsequent two years) contracts within the sport.

Why the Phillies would do it

Promote now, hope for later: Transferring on from Hoskins and Nola now and banking on gifted, however largely unproven expertise for later can be a high-profile dump by the Phillies. Dombrowski ought to (and certain would) not name it that. The Phillies would say the precise issues. However this may be a transfer for 2022 and 2023 greater than the current, particularly if the 22-year-old Garcia develops right into a frontline starter. That’s OK.

Reshape baseball’s worst protection: I’m not attempting to current Torres (who really can be higher at second base than shortstop) or Frazier (an journey in LF) as future Gold Glove winners. However change could be good, and the Phillies want to alter how this protection appears to be like. If a deal like this went down, the 2022 Phillies infield may appear to be this:

1B: Alec Bohm

2B: Torres

SS: Bryson Stott

3B: Jean Segura

And with Andrew McCutchen (who’s play is fading by the month) set to hit free company within the fall, Frazier could be the long-term left area resolution in Philadelphia.

Shopping for low on Torres may very well be sensible: Garcia’s upside is immense, however that is the important thing for the Phillies. Not too way back, Torres was talked about as a future MVP candidate. However his play has fallen off (each offensively and defensively) because the begin of the 2020 season. Is {that a} concern for the jewel of a deal? Positive. However let’s maintain all of it in perspective right here. Torres is in his age-24 season. He has 68 profession dwelling runs and an OPS+ of 120. Right here’s a full checklist of center infielders (second baseman or shortstops) to match or exceed that in MLB historical past: Alex Rodriguez, Cal Ripken Jr., Carlos Correa, Vern Stephens, Hanley Ramirez, and Nomar Garciaparra.

Is Torres seemingly nearer to, say, Ramirez than Rodriguez or Ripken? Sure, in fact. However touchdown a Ramirez-ish hitter with years of staff management left, shedding wage, and shaking up the core of a middling staff looks like a transfer Dombrowski must make.

Get Yankees textual content messages: Reduce by the litter of social media and textual content throughout video games with beat writers and columnists. Plus, unique information and evaluation every single day. Join now.

Please subscribe now and assist the native journalism YOU depend on and belief.

Joe Giglio could also be reached at

Related posts

Harm Notes: Chisholm, Duvall, Soler, Garcia


Daniel Murphy Retires – MLB Commerce Rumors


The Finest Minor League Offers Of 2021 (So Far): Place Gamers


Leave a Comment