Image default
College Football

Increasing the Faculty Soccer Playoff: The Case for a 16-Workforce Playoff

There’s nothing higher than a protracted day of Faculty Soccer. Every Saturday brings new twists and turns, a stunning upset or two, some jaw-dropping highlights, thrilling conclusions, and on the easiest of days – full chaos. Sadly, after a number of months of this, every season involves an unsatisfying conclusion. There are one or two significant video games, after which dozens of others that imply little outdoors of the faculties fanbase. This has been the case with the Coalition, the BCS, and nonetheless stays with the present four-team system. Not solely does it create a poor fan expertise, however the subjectivity for a way champions are decided is totally unfair and maddening.

The correct resolution is straightforward – a 16-team playoff.

I had an early style of the effectiveness and pure enjoyable of following a 16-team playoff system. I grew up a Cleveland sports activities fan, which taught me nothing however ache and distress. Then alongside got here Youngstown State turning into as a FCS (then I-AA) powerhouse. The Penguins received their first of 4 nationwide championships in 1991, and it was thrilling for me to see a staff from my yard win a nationwide title. However it was the best way that they received that made it so memorable.

First they needed to play properly sufficient all through the season to qualify for the playoffs. Regardless of the bigger pool, each recreation nonetheless completely mattered. Then it was a collection of win-or-go-home video games. In a championship season, that’s 4 consecutive video games with the whole lot on the road. The truth that YSU wasn’t sometimes one of the crucial gifted groups in FCS made it all of the extra compelling with every recreation they superior, and particularly after they hoisted the championship trophy.

There’s no query {that a} 16-team subject would create a vastly improved fan expertise. It additionally fixes lots of the different issues which have plagued how main faculty soccer champions are decided since…properly, eternally.

The present system nonetheless leaves a serious debate if the most effective groups are really being chosen. (For argument’s sake, let’s say issues will return to regular with a extra extensive open subject, reasonably than simply penciling in Alabama, Clemson, Ohio State and Oklahoma/Notre Dame/2nd SEC staff.)

Annually, there might be a slim hole between the fourth and fifth-ranked groups, leaving the committee (who notoriously change its unofficial standards from yr to yr) to subjectively choose the final staff in based mostly on the “eye check,” an insufficiently decided energy of schedule, judging the advantage of the out-of-conference schedule, and a slew of different objects. This argument will at all times stay alive and properly underneath the present system, and simply figuring out the fourth-seed has turn into its personal cottage business.

Nonetheless, this argument is totally eradicated in a 16-seed format. Certain, the groups which have their bubbles burst will doubtless consider they need to have gotten in, however we will rule out that one of many groups who didn’t qualify would have been capable of by some means put collectively a championship run. A quantity 5 seed would win all of it now and again, however it might be a as soon as in a lifetime second ought to a 17-seed do the identical, if ever.

This additionally offers all FBS packages a seat on the desk. Let’s say Bowling Inexperienced goes undefeated in 2021, together with non-conference wins towards Tennessee, Minnesota and the MAC Championship. Would they’ve any likelihood of getting within the playoffs subsequent season? Completely not. What in the event that they constructed on the undefeated season and went unbeaten once more in 2022? Nonetheless no. What in the event that they stored this up in 2023 nd 2024? They nonetheless received’t get a sniff from the committee, with their ceiling being a NY6 bowl victory towards a runner-up from a serious convention.

This additionally solves a newer problem that has additional downgraded the urge for food for many bowl video games – the absence of marquee gamers who decide to sit down out. This has turn into the norm for gamers projected to go within the first spherical (and at occasions, second, third and even additional down) who don’t wish to danger a extreme harm when their months away from an even bigger payday most of us will ever see in our lives. That is the case for any “main” bowl outdoors of the playoffs, and has completely taken the luster off of a number of the higher bowl video games that all of the sudden lack star energy.

Faculty soccer is probably the most superb spectacle of the sports activities world for 3 months, earlier than crashing down and ending with a thud every season. It’s far time to make the fixes in order that the postseason will match the depth and fervour seen in stadiums throughout the nation from Labor Day weekend via the primary week of December. The 16-team playoff is one of the best ways to reward followers by enhancing the general product, whereas giving everybody a seat on the desk for a extra truthful approach to crown a champion.

Related posts

School Soccer Playoff Enlargement Eventualities: The Case For Six Groups


Faculty Soccer Playoff breakdown: Who’re the ‘way-too-early’ prime contenders?


Can Oklahoma Attain the School Soccer Playoff Once more?


Leave a Comment